Tuesdays with Dorie: Marshmallows

My first Tuesdays with Dorie post!

The recipe for the week was marshmallows. I made them several years ago, and at that time I was surprised at how easy they were to make and how well they turned out. This time, things didn’t go as smoothly.


Sunday, the day that I had set aside to make the recipe, was chilly and rainy in Seattle – quite a contrast to Saturday’s warm, sunny weather. (We do get the odd tease of summer weather in April here in the Pacific Northwest.) So much for keeping the marshmallows cool AND dry. It’s amazing that they turned out as well as they did, actually. I was a bit distracted as we’re trying to fix up our basement, and several times I was called to run downstairs to hold a piece of plywood that Mark was sawing, or drill screws into a piece of pegboard. I ended up overbeating the egg whites, but I went ahead and beat the sugar syrup and gelatin into them and they looked fine. When I laid the mixture out on the baking tray, though, I had a bit of trouble smoothing it and keeping it level to one inch. The result was less-than-lovely, unevenly sized marshmallows. Unlike the beautiful ones pictured in Dorie’s book, mine were brutti ma buoni – ugly but good.



The best part was playing around with different coatings for the plain vanilla marshmallows. I decided to divide the batch of cut marshmallows into thirds, with a different coating for each. I toasted some coconut for one.



I grated nutmeg into some powdered sugar for another.



I had some dark cocoa I thought would make a nice contrast with the white marshmallows, so I mixed some of that with some cinnamon and espresso powder, like one of Dorie’s “playing around” flavorings.





Mark emerged from the basement to ohh and ahh and gobble a coconut-coated marshmallow. I took the rest to work yesterday and they were a big hit. People were amazed by the seeming alchemy of it. “You made marshmallows!?!”




   I have to miss next week’s carrot cake recipe, but I’m looking forward to whatever comes after that.



Filed under marshmallows, Tuesday with Dorie

8 responses to “Tuesdays with Dorie: Marshmallows

  1. Welcome, welcome! Wish I’d thought of nutmeg. What a good idea.

  2. Great job! I love seeing all the different takes and ideas with this group!

  3. LyB

    I like the ones with the cocoa coating, beautiful!

  4. Wow, those look great! I love your ideas for sprinkles: nutmeg and powdered sugar and cinnamon and espresso powder. Great job!

  5. Welcome aboard! Your marshmallow buffet looks good enough to eat! I’ll have a coconut coated one, thanks! 😉

  6. Welcome! Those came out great!

  7. I am new to this group as well and what a fun recipe to start with! Yours look GREAT! I like the coating idea, I will have to try that next time.

  8. I like the idea of coating the vanilla ones with different flavors. Seattle, eh? I bet the humidity had an effect. (I grew up near there.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s